Dan Markovitz
August 15, 2016

ARTICLE: In Praise of Ignorance

Daniel Markovitz is the author of two Shingo Research Award-winning books, Building the Fit Organization and A Factory of One. He holds a Stanford MBA, and is a faculty member at the Lean Enterprise Institute, a lecturer at Ohio State’s Fisher College of Business, and teaches at the Stanford University Graduate School of Business. You can learn more about Dan at his blog, or follow him on twitter @danmarkovitz.


If you have a deep reservoir of experience with lean and a desire to help companies reap its benefits, there’s a nearly irresistible temptation to foist your understanding of improvement upon the people working in the organization rather than allowing people to learn and improve in their own way. As John Shook (the CEO of the Lean Enterprise Institute) put it:

"The notion of experts, often authorized through a certification process, too often devolves into an approach to improvement in which teams of experts swoop in to “do improvement to” the people who are trying to do the work, the frontline value-creating work of the business. "

It doesn’t feel that way, of course. It feels like real help. With the best of intentions, you deploy your proprietary conceptual model for improvement that has worked so many times before. You expertly map value streams; identify improvement opportunities; install kanbans for inventory control; create better layouts for manufacturing cells; and set up visual management systems to monitor work processes.

The motives are pure—after all, you’ll get results more quickly, which is good for your customer. But over the long run, individual recidivism and operational regression to the mean is unavoidable. If you doubt that, just try listing the number of organizations that you think have really succeeded with continuous improvement. I bet it’s a pretty short list.

 Mark Rosenthal, an outstanding lean consultant in the US, puzzled why so many organizations plateaued in their pursuit of lean. He found that experts,

"were essentially pushing them [managers] aside and “fixing” things, then turning the newly “leaned” area over to the supervisors and first line managers who, at most, might have participated in the workshop and helped move things around. So it really should be no surprise that come Monday morning, when the inevitable forces of entropy showed up, that things started to erode." 

There were no experts when the Toyota Production System was first being developed. Without years of experience practicing lean, and without a codified system of knowledge, no one was an expert—not even Taiichi Ohno. Workers, supervisors, and managers saw problems and groped their way towards solutions without guidance—because there was no one who actually could provide guidance. The tools that today’s experts eagerly deploy were developed organically by the workers directly affected by those problems in the pursuit of a countermeasure to a specific situation. But they developed those countermeasures by themselves. 

I haven’t worked at Toyota—or even at a company that embraced continuous improvement. I haven’t been insulted by Shingijutsu consultants in the course of a five-day kaizen. The only black belt I have is from Men’s Wearhouse, not from a lean six sigma program. I doubt Jim Womack or Dan Jones could pick me out of a police lineup. If I’m honest about it, the depth of my knowledge of the Toyota Production System is like a kid’s wading pool compared to the ocean of wisdom of the deeply experienced lean thinkers in the world. But in some ways, I think this makes me a better consultant when I help companies in their lean journeys.

A few months ago, I was working with a client on a shipping problem. Their biggest customer changed their policies, and instituted a penalty if their weekly orders weren’t received by Wednesday. This was a full day earlier than my client had been able to ship up to that point, so they were facing either a near-certainty of chargebacks, or the need to hire more workers in the warehouse. 

What I don’t know about warehouse operations could, well, fill a warehouse—and at that point, I had never done any improvement work in a warehouse. As a result, there was no way for me to “do improvement to” the distribution team, even if I wanted to. What I do know, however, is that in most processes where speed is an issue (as opposed to, for example, quality or safety), the waste of waiting is enormous. And with that level of lean knowledge, I could encourage the the improvement project team to simply walk through the shipping process and look for places where people were waiting for information or materials. 

Sure enough, the workers saw the needless handoffs and the unnecessary steps that forced the pickers and packers to wait. They developed the improvements to eliminate those wastes and smooth the flow of products and information through the process. And they’ve continued to modify and improve that process every few weeks, as they come up with new ideas. They’ve cut the time needed to process the shipment from three days to one or one and a half (depending on the order size).

 Had my lean experience been deeper, I probably would have taught them process mapping, designed visual controls, and helped them level the workload of the various departments involved. They would have dutifully followed my instructions, but they’d never have owned the improvements. Performance would probably have slipped over time—and without a doubt, they certainly wouldn’t have continued to tweak the system to make it work even better. 

If your continuous improvement efforts are stalling, consider whether you’re relying too much on experts who are “doing lean to” people. The fathers of lean didn’t have experts they could rely on, and they did pretty well. Maybe you should try professing ignorance and letting the workers solve the problems.

View Dan's Profile

Download the most comprehensive OpEx Resport in the Industry

The Largest Leadership-Level Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Event

The Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Industry Awards Video Presentation

Proqis Events Schedule

Proqis Digital

The Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Industry Awards

Welcome to BTOES Insights, the content portal for Business Transformation & Operational Excellence opinions, reports & news.
Access all 75 Award Finalist Entires
Subscribe to Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Insights Now

Featured Content

  • Best Achievement of Operational Excellence in Technology & Communications: IBM
  • Best Achievement of Operational Excellence in Oil & Gas, Power & Utilities: Black & Veatch
  • Best Achievement in Cultural Transformation to deliver a high performing Operational Excellence culture: NextEra Energy
Operational Excellence Frameworks and Learning Resources, Customer Experience, Digital Transformation and more introductions
  • Intelligent BPM Systems: Impact & Opportunity
  • Surviving_the_IT_Talent_deficit.png
  • Six Sigma's Best Kept Secret: Motorola & The Malcolm Baldrige Awards
  • The Value-Switch for Digitalization Initiatives: Business Process Management
  • Process of Process Management: Strategy Execution in a Digital World

Popular Tags

Operational Excellence Business Transformation Business Improvement Process Management Continuous Improvement Business Excellence process excellence Process Optimization Process Improvement Leadership Enterprise Excellence Change Management Lean Premium Organizational Excellence Lean Enterprise Lean Six Sigma Execution Excellence Capability Excellence Award Finalist Case Study New Technologies Changing & Improving Company Culture end-to-end Business Transformation Digital Transformation Agile Execution & Sustaining OpEx Projects Culture Transformation Lack of/Need for Resources Leadership Understanding & Buy-In Adapting to Business Trends Changing Customer Demands Failure to Innovate Integrating CI Methodologies Lack of/Need for Skilled Workers Lack of/Need for Support from Employees Maintaining key Priorities Relationships Between Departments BTOES18 Technology Healthcare and Medical Devices Culture Customer Experience Process Automation Exclusive BTOES Video Presentations BTOES HEALTH Innovation Strategy Execution Report Manufacturing Customer Experience Excellence Healthcare BPM Lean Manufacturing Artificial Intelligence Digital value creation Agility Insurance Robotic Process Automation Systems Engineering digital operations Process Design innovation execution data management Awards Industry Data Analytics Sustainability Transformation thought leaders BTOES Presentation Slides Data Automation Machine Learning Banking and Capital Markets Finance Speaker Presentation Professional Services IT AI Enterprise Excellence culture Robotic Process Automation (RPA) Sales Cultural Transformation Education HealthcareTechnologies White Paper investment banking BTOES19 Consumer Products & Retail Electricity Health Insurance Operational Excellence Model Project Management Algorithm Automotive and Transportation Banking Blockchain Cloud Digital Bank Digital Global Enterprise Model (D-GEM) Lean Culture Primary Measure of succes Python business expansion revenue growth AI Solution Innovation in Healthcare Business Intelligence CAIR (Client Advocacy Insights Robot) Digital Technologies Government HR Health Maintenance Organizations Interview Learning organization Medicare Operational Excellence Example User Interface business process automation transformation journey Accounts Receivable (AR) Agile Transformation Big Data Technology Business Environment CORE Cloud Technology Cognitive learning Data Entry Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) Delivery solution Digital Network Digital Network Assistant (DNA) Digitization Drinks Global Technology Healthy Culture Information Systems Internet Logistics Services Media NPS Natural Language Processing Net Promoter Score Optimise Business Processes Program Management Portal (PgMP) Relationship Management Risk Management Six Sigma AEGIS Database Adobe Sign Automated Money Movement BPaaS Biopharmaceutical BlueFIT Business Benefits CX Capability Capital Market Case Study Corporate Culture Digital Workforce Digitalization E-Signatures ERP Transformation Enterprice Excellence Culture Filmed Entertainment Industry Financial Services Software Frameworks Government Programs Hoshin Planning Hospitality Implementation Kaizen Event Operational Excellence (OpEx) Organizational Learning Pharmaceutical Pharmaceuticals & Life Sciences ST-Elevation Myocardial Infarction (STEMI) Servant Leadership Strategic Business Transformation Strategic Priorities Supply Chain Management Sustainable Growth Team Leader Development Program (TLDP) Transformation Initiatives Transportation Wealth Protection Products Web Logic Portal Workplace Analytics eForms eSignatures BEAM BFARM BTOES17 Big Data Processing Blue Room Effect Business Analytics Business Challenges Business Growth Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) Centralized Performance Monitoring System Child Care Program Client Feedback Strategy Communication Creative Passion Creativity Denial Management Digital Experience Digital Technology Educational Psychologist Effective Change Leaders Employee Empowerment Finance Global Operations (FGO) Global Enterprise Model© (GEM) Hospitality & Construction Human Capital Human Centered Design Integrated Decision Approach Integrated Decision Making Kaizen Natural Gas Infrastructure Natural Language Processing (NLP) Offering Managers Oil and Gas Optical Character Recognition (OCR) Organizational Change Organizational Goal People Engagement Program (PEP!) Pharmaceuticals and Life Sciences Photographing Positive Workplace Environment Price and Routing Tracking (PART) Product Identifier Descriptions (PIDs) Project manager Quote to Cash (Q2C) SAP Sales Quota Telecommunications Text Mining Visually Displayed eHealth master text analytics virtual resource management Agile methodology Announcement Augmented Intelligence BTOES18 Award Winners BTOES18 Awards