Back then most Black Belts had some exposure to "lean", we knew the basic tools and methods and saw where they could make our projects easier, faster, etc - it just made sense.
There was a short period where a whole multitude of terms were popping up to describe this newfangled combination:
In 2002, Michael George authored
"Lean Six Sigma: Combining Six Sigma Quality with Lean Production Speed".
From then on, it was "Lean Six Sigma" for the win.
It was also the point at which the evolution of "lean" seemed to take two divergent paths:
The common understanding of lean at the point of Michael George's book, was in fact very heavy on "Just in Time" concepts and tools, so I understand why Lean Six Sigma defined lean in that fashion. Right or wrong, it was still common at the time.
But at the same time, lean was still being understood. It was about the same time "The Toyota Way", by Jeff Liker came out.
[A big improvement in the understanding of lean at that point but still not perfect]
The was probably the start of a mainstream divergence that saw lean as something more than "Just in Time" and low inventories.
Yes I know there were still people out there that knew better, and were trying to be heard, but the majority of people were still learning about lean from the myriad of consultants out there, all plugging that "Lean is about Process Velocity".
This view has been so persistent that there are still professionals and consultants out there that actually believe applying lean without Six Sigma would somehow result in “making bad stuff faster."
No really...I've actually heard people say this.
Hey I understand - if you were taught to view lean that way, then you might think those things are true. I did for several years.
No more though...we know so much more about lean now there's no excuse any more to keep repeating this stuff. If you believe in continuing education, then it's time to reeducate yourself on lean.
Besides, you're actually offending the "lean crowd" and there's no reason to have a wall between the two sides, they just want lean represented accurately.
Do you get upset when someone says Six Sigma is just a bunch of quality tools? Exactly...so let's all keep an open mind and continue to learn from each other.
[Rule Number 1: Don't take my explanation as gospel, or anyone else's - do your own research and see for yourself]
Well it's no wonder there's so much confusion, cause you won't even get a single consistent answer from the "lean crowd" as to what is lean. But I'll give it a shot.
[This is very, very hard, because for all the talk about lean being simple, it's not. It IS a bunch of concepts that sound simple, but are very hard to do well - all at once]
Lean is comprised of three organizational aspects:
So if you look at how this works in Toyota, you could conceive of a diagram like the following:
Common Philosophy:
"Toyota Way 2001", which is Toyota's expression of the their guiding principles that reflect the kind of company that Toyota seeks to be.
This is the idea that building mutual respect among people best comes from collaborative problem solving.
These are complimentary and mutually inclusiveideas:
Common Techniques and Methods
This is the common "TPS Temple" or "House of Lean" that gets depicted. It's an expression of the technical way Toyota approaches production.
A Foundation of Stability, made possible through Heijunka (Leveling), Standardized Work, and Kaizen.
Two equal pillars of "Just in Time" and "Jidoka"(Built in Quality).
[Just in Time is just one piece of this whole puzzle - see how much you're missing out on?]
Just this technical aspect shows how lean would NEVER "make defects faster".
You can only increase process velocity at the rate for which quality and stability will allow - each serves the other.
Common Managerial Rules
This perspective actually comes from Steven J. Spear, a senior lecturer at MIT Sloan School of Management. His research into Toyota's ability to "outrace their competition by out learning them" lead to the formation of 4 basic capabilities and 4 basic rules that Toyota and other highly effective organizations operate under:
The Four Capabilities:
Update 1/26/2015: I forget to mention that why all this is a great academic explanation of the managerial aspects - it also has to include an org structure that "allows" leaders to be teachers.
Can you teach / develop 20 people at once? Congratulations if you said yes, cause I know I can't...at least not effectively.
Toyota and other lean organizations usually have a very low ratio of team members to leaders, sometimes as low as 1:4, but rarely higher than 1:10.
These small teams are the environment that allow the 4 Capabilities to be effectively developed. Without that environment, and those skills you likely won't have collaboration, mutual trust, continuous improvement, Jidoka, etc.
Stop and Fix - Show Respect. You get the idea.
Hard to do when you never see your leader and don't feel respected.
The Four Rules [of Process Design]
I ended with that last point on purpose...the scientific method.
In lean, the scientific method is commonly expressed as applying the Plan, Do, Check, Act cycle.
Everything, and I mean everything in lean is centered around the PDCA cycle.
How you improve processes, how you train people, how you develop new products, how you plan strategically - PDCA, PDCA, PDCA.
[Did I mention PDCA?]
So perhaps we've already made it more complicated than it needs to be. I'll end with a quote from former Toyota President, Fujio Cho that verbalized the continuous application of the PDCA cycle in Toyota:
We place the highest value on actual implementation and taking action. There are many things one doesn't understand and therefore, we ask them why don’t you just go ahead and take action; try to do something? You realize how little you know and you face your own failures and you simply can correct those failures and redo it again and at the second trial you realize another mistake or another thing you didn't like so you can redo it once again. So by constant improvement, or, should I say, the improvement based upon action, one can rise to the higher level of practice and knowledge.
~~Fujio Cho, President, Toyota Motor Corporation, 2002
View Nick's Contributor Profile
Nick will be speaking in March 2017 at the Business Transformation & Operational Excellence World Summit. To learn more, visit btoes.com.
View our schedule of industry leading free to attend virtual conferences. Each a premier gathering of industry thought leaders and experts sharing key solutions to current challenges.
View Schedule of Events-------------------------------------------------------
Search for anything
Insights from the most progressive thought leaders delivered to your inbox.
Insights from the world's foremost thought leaders delivered to your inbox.
Being a hero is all about creating value for others. Please invite up to 5 people in your network to attend this premier virtual conference, and they will receive an invitation to attend.
If it’s easier for you, please enter your email address below, and click the button, and we will send you the invitation email that you can forward to relevant people in your network.
View our schedule of industry leading free to attend virtual conferences. Each a premier gathering of industry thought leaders and experts sharing key solutions to current challenges.
View Schedule of EventsWatch On-Demand Recording - Access all sessions from progressive thought leaders free of charge from our industry leading virtual conferences.
Watch On-Demand Recordings For FreeDelivered by the industry's most progressive thought leaders from the world's top brands. Start learning today!
View All Courses NowThe premier Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Conference. Watch sessions on-demand for free. Use code: BFH1120
Watch On-DemandInsights from the most progressive thought leaders delivered to your inbox.
Insights from the world's foremost thought leaders delivered to your inbox.
Being a hero is all about creating value for others. Please invite up to 5 people in your network to also access our newsletter. They will receive an invitation and an option to subscribe.
If it’s easier for you, please enter your email address below, and click the button, and we will send you the invitation email that you can forward to relevant people in your network.
Courtesy of Nintex Pty's Paul Hsu, below is a transcript of his speaking session on 'Improve employee productivity during and post-COVID by ...
Read this article about HP, Best Achievement in Operational Excellence to deliver Digital Transformation, selected by the independent judging panel, ...
Read this article about BMO Financial Group, one of our finalists, in the category Best Achievement in Operational Excellence to deliver Digital ...
Read this article about Cisco, one of our finalists, in the category Best Achievement of Operational Excellence in Internet, Education, Media & ...