Twila Burdick
By
December 24, 2018

Improving the Reliability of Care and the Healthcare Culture


Twila Burdick has written an article on her interpretation of the Global State of Operational Excellence Survey Report - Critical Challenges & Future Trends - 2018/2019.  Click here to download the full Survey Report 2018/19.  

The Most Comprehensive Study of Critical Challenges and Future Trends within Operational Excellence

With nearly 1000 respondents, 37 insightful questions, detailed analysis & insights from 40 industry thought leaders, and the BTOES Insights executive team, this 130 page report is recognised as the most comprehensive study of critical challenges and future trends within Operational Excellence, and is considered a key resource for the industry. Areas covered include:

  • The Critical Operational Excellence Challenges faced by executives.

  • The Current Scope of Operational Excellence.

  • How is Operational Excellence success measured?

  • Key Findings & Roadblocks.

  • What are executives focusing on over the next 12-18 months?

  • What have been the greatest developments?

  • What are the key drivers pushing change in Operational Excellence?

  • Industry Perspectives.

  • Small, Medium & Large Corporation Perspectives.

  • Detail Analysis & Insights from BTOES Insights Executive Team.

  • Detailed Analysis & Insights from 40 Industry Thought Leaders.

  • Analysis of key themes, including Cultural Transformation, Customer Delight, Sustaining an Operational Excellence program, Need for end-to-end Business Transformation, Keeping up with new technologies/impact of digitalization and Leadership Buy-in & Understanding.

 

Research report front cover

 

Complete form to access Report now

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

Improving the Reliability of Care and the Healthcare Culture

As in the past, this year’s “The Global State of Operational Excellence” report provides an insightful snapshot of the issues facing organizations committed to reliably executing business strategy in pursuit of delighting their customers better than their competitors.  It is no surprise that changing company culture is at the top of the list, with 53.1% of the respondents identifying it as their most critical challenge. Click here to read the full Survey Report 2018/19. 

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

 

While changing culture is a problem for all industries, healthcare faces some unique challenges.  

Clinical care delivery is labor intensive with many people involved in performing different interdependent functions with a key role being that of the physician. Click here to read more Articles on The Global State of Operational Excellence: Critical Challenges & Future Trends - Research Report 2018/19.

Improving the Reliability of Care and the Healthcare Culture

Physicians are highly trained professionals who make diagnostic and treatment decisions, exercising individual professional judgement. This dependence on individual autonomy and performance, a deep cultural assumption, makes care reliability--doing the right things right—very difficult.

Healthcare has a profound effect on individual pain and suffering and because of that and its cost, there is significant interest in understanding how healthcare can be transformed.  Researchers have been studying change efforts that have worked and what has made them successful.

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

 

Health care researchers in 2016*presented a conceptual framework for analyzing the adoption of innovations in healthcare based on emerging implementation science identified four attributes that influence the adoption of innovations:

  1. external environment

  2. characteristics of the organization

  3. characteristics of the innovation such as the quality of evidence

  4. implementation process

In 2017**, social scientists reviewed a large-scale healthcare delivery improvement, the Michigan project to reduce central line infections, and concluded that the results could be attributed to implementing an evidence-based checklist along with cultural change as described by Dr. Peter Pronovost,  “creating clinical communities and influencing peer norms”. He said that changing clinical practice required both technical and adaptive factors, “the science must be robust, yet it must address values, beliefs, and attributes of the groups involved”, underscoring the importance of culture.

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

 

Banner Health

Banner Health, a regional healthcare provider consisting of more than 25 hospitals and other services with corporate offices in Phoenix, Arizona, assessed the healthcare environment and made a strategic decision to improve clinical care reliability. Recognizing the pivotal role of physicians in clinical decision making, it asked doctors to apply “evidence” from clinical research to care practices. An improvement process referred to as “Define-Design-Implement” (as shown below) provided a framework for the implementation.

Improving the Reliability of Care and the Healthcare Culture

 

Physicians were asked to join and lead multi-disciplinary Clinical Consensus Groups (CCGs) organized by medical specialty (e.g., obstetrics, emergency care).  Members of CCGs met regularly and identified “evidence-based practices”. Drawing on their training as scientists, CCG members read journal articles, consulted with professional societies, and met with colleagues to “define” the clinical conditions and their appropriate treatment. This part of the process focused on doing the right thing.

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

 

"Design", simulation and implementation 

Following agreement, clinical practices went through a “design” step to be sure that the details of what needed to be done could be put in place, including supplies, clinical automation, staff training, and more. Whenever possible, computerized decision support aids were developed to assist physicians with their diagnosis and treatment decisions, rather than asking them to rely solely on memory. The design process was led by engineers with expertise in how processes can best be efficient and effective.  After design was completed, it was tested in a simulated environment or onsite to ensure that the design made it possible to do things right.

After the design was tested, it was “implemented” according to a detailed plan that allowed for time to train people at the front lines and communicate the changes broadly.  

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

 

Metrics for performance

To close the loop, metrics for performance were monitored by the CCGs.  This included leading and lagging indicators, that were automatically generated by clinical technology systems whenever possible.  Issues identified could then be addressed whether they were related to individual performance or the system design.

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

 

Physician autonomy

This effort was led by the organization’s Chief Medical Officer, a senior officer who was part of the senior management team.  His involvement in the work demonstrated the organization’s commitment to physicians. He also ensured that resources to support the CCGs were put in place, adding skills related to process engineering, project management, data analysis, and informatics.

Because physician autonomy has been such an important part of the clinical care delivery culture, the development and implementation of consistent clinical practices across the organization was a significant, tangible change. Physicians in the CCGs demonstrated that they wanted to improve care for all patients by applying the best science available even when it meant changing their own practice, a powerful example for their colleagues as well as for other clinical disciplines.  Clinical automation enabled evidence-based care delivery. This new way of “acting” led to a different way of “thinking” about clinical decision making, changing the culture of clinical care.

Banner’s success in reducing clinical variation with this approach took place over several years with documented  improvement results in a number of areas. More than 20 CCGs with more than 200 clinicians as members were formed and structures and resources to support the work were put in place.  

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

 

Clinical Research 

The clinical improvement research cited earlier provided a lens to review Banner’s experience with clinical reliability.  Banner’s technical approach included defining clinical standards based on clinical research, designing delivery processes according to engineering principles, and implementing and monitoring progress on an ongoing basis. It addressed cultural factors by engaging clinical decision makers in the process, honoring their clinical expertise, and supporting their ongoing work.  The importance of the external environment that is pushing for improvement along with the internal structures and resources was recognized. The integrity of changes based on clinical research was key as well-trained clinicians found it hard to argue against the evidence and the engagement of the physicians in the overall implementation was vital.

 

Changing culture in every industry will continue to be challenging, but the Banner experience demonstrated that in healthcare, improvement in clinical care is possible and barriers to change created by the culture can be addressed, an important lesson learned.

 

Want to learn more? Download the full Report.
Improving the Reliability of Care and the Healthcare Culture

pillar%20page%20line%201

About the Author 

Twila Burdick: Improving the Reliability of Care and the Healthcare CultureTwila Burdick

Vice President (retired) Organizational Performance, Banner Health

Twila Burdick served as the Vice President of Organizational Performance in the Care Management division of Banner Health, a leading integrated accountable healthcare organization meeting the health needs of residents in six western states through its hospitals and academic medical centers, clinics, urgent care centers, and more. Banner has been recognized as one of the country’s “Top Health Systems”, and also as having a “Top Leadership Team” in recent years. She was based at Banner’s corporate headquarters in Phoenix, Arizona and worked across the entire organization.

She is a fellow of the Healthcare Information Management Systems Society (HIMSS) and has published and presented at numerous national and regional conferences about work done at Banner. She was co-principal investigator for an Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) patient safety project, working with a research team from Arizona State University. Check out her LinkedIn page.

Prior to her retirement in 2017, she provided leadership for the Care Management Division and directly oversaw Case and Quality Management, Clinical Outcomes Analysis, Process Engineering, Clinical Informatics and several systemwide Care Management teams.

She holds a Master’s Degree in Business Administration from the University of Montana.

pillar%20page%20line%201

References:

* Fisher ES, Shortell SM, Savitz LA. Implementation Science – A Potential   Catalyst for Delivery System Reform. JAMA. 2016;315(4): 339-340.

* Henig, Robin Marantz, “The Hospital Checklist: How Social Science Insights Improve Health Outcomes”, From Research to Reward, National Academy of Sciences, February 2017.

 

pillar%20page%20line%201

BTOES.com

The issues in this article are just one of topic areas that are going to be discussed at the Business Transformation & Operational Excellence World Summit & Industry (BTOES19). March 18-22, 2019, Loews Portofino Bay Hotel at Universal Orlando Resort®

BTOES is the industry’s biggest and best, senior-level, cross-industry gathering of Business Transformation & Operational Excellence industry leaders and senior executives.

It also hosts the Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Awards, which showcase globally the most outstanding organizational achievements through the application of Operational Excellence programs.

The summits hosts a number of private forums for C-Level & Global corporate-level leaders as well as business unit heads.

With over 150 speakers, over 100 sessions, 12 Keynotes, 9 Track Themes, 5 parallel tracks, 60+ track sessions, 50 roundtable discussions, 20 Interactive Workshops, 6 Thought Leader Panels, 5 Leaders Boardrooms, 5 co-located events, the Industry Awards Program, Site Visits, 20+ hours of social networking including 2 gala cocktail parties, dinners, numerous group activities, this is the ultimate event to benchmark, network and drive Operational Excellence to the next level.

 

Quick Links

Speakers

Agenda

BTOES19 Awards

 

There is a strong focus on Cultural Transformation, Customer Delight, Sustaining an Operational Excellence program, Need for end-to-end Business Transformation, Keeping up with new technologies/impact of digitalization and Leadership Buy-in & Understanding. We dedicated two tracks to advanced technologies, such as AI, Machine Learning, RPA, Predictive Analytics, Blockchain, Cloud infrastructure etc.

 

The agenda is designed to encourage active meaningful conversations though all day enhanced networking and interaction opportunities, including

  • All-day Refreshment & Themed Breaks

  • 1¼ Hour Hot Breakfast Networking Sessions

  • 1½ Hour Hot Plated Networking Lunches with Topic & Industry Sector focussed tables

  • 1½ Hour Roundtable Sessions by Topic & Industry Sector.

  • Keynote & Themes Panel Sessions

  • Hosted Welcome Receptions from 5.30pm

  • Expanded more lavish Awards Program

  • Newly launched Night Summit for attendees to meet after dinner

For more information or to discuss the summit in more detail please schedule a call below,

Click here to schedule a call. 

 

Download the most comprehensive OpEx Resport in the Industry

The Largest Leadership-Level Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Event

The Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Industry Awards

Welcome to BTOES Insights, the content portal for Business Transformation & Operational Excellence opinions, reports & news.

------------------------------ 

EXCLUSIVE SERIES: BTOES17 VIDEO PRESENTATIONS

Full-length speaking sessions from the Business Transformation & Operational Excellence World Summit, accompanied by featured articles from the Speakers themselves.

WATCH NOW

-------------------------------

Submit an Article

Become a Regular Contributor

504x672
AWARD 2019-1
Copy of Copy of btoes19
Subscribe to Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Insights Now
btoes19.png
png
certificate
png
btoes19healthcare
png
3-30
png
Copy of Copy of btoes19 (1)
png

Featured Content

  • Best Achievement of Operational Excellence in Technology & Communications: IBM
  • Best Achievement of Operational Excellence in Oil & Gas, Power & Utilities: Black & Veatch
  • Best Achievement in Cultural Transformation to deliver a high performing Operational Excellence culture: NextEra Energy
   
Operational Excellence Frameworks and Learning Resources, Customer Experience, Digital Transformation and more introductions
  • Intelligent BPM Systems: Impact & Opportunity
  • Surviving_the_IT_Talent_deficit.png
  • Six Sigma's Best Kept Secret: Motorola & The Malcolm Baldrige Awards
  • The Value-Switch for Digitalization Initiatives: Business Process Management
  • Process of Process Management: Strategy Execution in a Digital World

Popular Tags

Operational Excellence Business Transformation Business Improvement Process Management Continuous Improvement Business Excellence Process Optimization process excellence Process Improvement Leadership Premium Enterprise Excellence Change Management Lean Lean Enterprise Execution Excellence Organizational Excellence Lean Six Sigma BTOES18 Capability Excellence Culture Transformation Changing & Improving Company Culture New Technologies end-to-end Business Transformation Agile Execution & Sustaining OpEx Projects Lack of/Need for Resources Leadership Understanding & Buy-In Adapting to Business Trends Changing Customer Demands Failure to Innovate Integrating CI Methodologies Lack of/Need for Skilled Workers Lack of/Need for Support from Employees Maintaining key Priorities Relationships Between Departments Digital Transformation Healthcare and Medical Devices Culture Customer Experience Exclusive BTOES HEALTH BTOES Video Presentations Technology Strategy Execution Innovation Process Automation Report Manufacturing BPM Lean Manufacturing Agility Systems Engineering Process Design Awards Healthcare BTOES Presentation Slides Insurance value creation thought leaders Robotic Process Automation innovation execution Customer Experience Excellence data management Professional Services Banking and Capital Markets Data Analytics digital operations White Paper BTOES19 Consumer Products & Retail Operational Excellence Model Project Management Artificial Intelligence Automotive and Transportation Digital business expansion revenue growth Interview Operational Excellence Example investment banking Lean Culture NPS Net Promoter Score Six Sigma Data Frameworks Hoshin Planning Learning organization Pharmaceuticals & Life Sciences Primary Measure of succes Workplace Analytics business process automation transformation journey BTOES17 Business Growth Client Feedback Strategy Communication Denial Management Education HealthcareTechnologies Hospitality & Construction Human Centered Design Innovation in Healthcare Integrated Decision Approach Integrated Decision Making Kaizen Oil and Gas Pharmaceuticals and Life Sciences Supply Chain Management Telecommunications Text Mining eHealth master text analytics virtual resource management Announcement BTOES18 Award Winners BTOES18 Awards Communications Infographic Jidoka Learning Resource Oil & Gas Recruitment Team The FAST lane