Chris Seifert
By
November 30, 2016

ARTICLE: Stopping Unsafe Acts Shouldn’t be a “Right”

Have you told your employees that they have the “right” or the “authority” to stop work when they see something unsafe? 

Screenshot 2016-11-30 21.28.05.png

Have you told employees that they shouldn’t fear reprisal if they report unsafe conditions or acts?  If so, you need to rethink what you’ve told them.  You may not be sending the right message.

In the past I’ve written about the need to treat safety as an “expectation” rather than a “goal” or “priority”, and the implications that change in mindset has for how we lead, communicate, and incentivize our teams.  In summary, if we truly want to create a workplace free from injuries and incidents, we need to stop telling our teams that it is our goal that they don’t get injured.  Instead, we need to tell them that it is our “expectation” that they don’t get hurt.

Similarly, leaders should take a close look at how they talk about an employee’s “right” to stop or report an unsafe act.  When we tell employees they have the “right” to stop work, we are telling them that if they see something they don’t think is safe, it’s “ok” for them to stop work.  The implication is that they won’t get in trouble if they stop work. 

But what if they see something they think might be unsafe and choose not to report it?  When we tell people they have the “right” to stop something unsafe, we aren’t telling them that they have an “obligation” to report something unsafe.  But isn’t that what we should be telling them?  Shouldn’t we be telling them that if they have any information that they even think might indicate something is unsafe they have an obligation to say something?

Screenshot 2016-11-30 21.44.10.png

This subtle difference in organizational culture and language is one of the factors that enables high-reliability organizations (HROs) to achieve extraordinary levels of safety and reliability despite operating in complex, high-risk environments.  In HROs, employees are expected to demonstrate a questioning attitude and to back each other upThey have an obligation to report things that may be unsafe.  They don’t fear reprisal for reporting unsafe actions.  Rather, they fear that if they don’t report something unsafe they will be held accountable.

Creating this kind of culture requires very nuanced changes in leadership behavior.  Allow me to illustrate with an example from my time serving as an officer aboard a U.S. Navy submarine. 

On a fast-attack submarine the Commanding Officer’s (CO) stateroom is right next to the control room, where the Officer of the Deck (OOD) and his team navigate and drive the boat.  The CO’s stateroom is wired for sound and has numerous screens that display information from sonar, fire control, and navigation so he can monitor everything going on in control.  Very late one night we were conducting periscope operations when the OOD gave an order to the Helmsman to change course.  The CO immediately stormed out of his stateroom and asked one of the Sonar Techs if he agreed with the order the OOD had just given.  The Sonar Tech, one of the most junior sailors in the control room at the time, was astonished.  After a brief pause he replied that he did not.  The CO told him quite sternly that it was his obligation to back-up the OOD, and then he promptly returned to his stateroom. 

 It turned out that the Sonar Tech’s information panel indicated that the course the OOD ordered was heading directly towards another ship.  Now, there were several other people in the control room that were senior to the Sonar Tech that should have known this, including me (I was on the periscope) and the OOD.  The CO could have come out and stopped us and asked why we weren’t paying attention to what was going on.  But instead, he went straight to one of the most junior sailor’s and confronted him.  Why?  Because he was teaching that junior sailor that if he had information that something might be unsafe, he had an obligation to report it.  I assure you, that Sonar Tech was no longer afraid that he would get in trouble for challenging a senior officer’s order.  Instead, he was afraid he would get in trouble if he didn’t. 

Creating a culture where reporting unsafe conditions is an “obligation” rather than a “right” is critical to truly achieving a workplace free from incidents.  Using the right language to communicate that obligation results in subtle, but very powerful changes in employee perceptions and behaviors.

View Chris's Contributor Profile

BTOE_Awards_Long_Ad.png


Download the most comprehensive OpEx Resport in the Industry

Welcome to BTOES Insights, the content portal for Business Transformation & Operational Excellence opinions, reports & news.
The Global State of Operational Excellence: 2017 Industry Report
Subscribe to Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Insights Now

Featured Content

  • Best Achievement of Operational Excellence in Technology & Communications: IBM
  • Best Achievement of Operational Excellence in Oil & Gas, Power & Utilities: Black & Veatch
  • Best Achievement in Cultural Transformation to deliver a high performing Operational Excellence culture: NextEra Energy
    
Official Media Partner: Business Transformation & Operational Excellence World Summit
Operational Excellence Frameworks and Learning Resources, Customer Experience, Digital Transformation and more introductions
Business Transformation & Operational Excellence World Summit - BTOES17 - Watch the highlights now!
The Business Transformation & Operational Excellence Awards 2018
  • Intelligent BPM Systems: Impact & Opportunity
  • Surviving_the_IT_Talent_deficit.png
  • Six Sigma's Best Kept Secret: Motorola & The Malcolm Baldrige Awards
  • The Value-Switch for Digitalization Initiatives: Business Process Management
  • Process of Process Management: Strategy Execution in a Digital World